Post by @stefano@bsd.cafe

Stefano Marinelli
@stefano @bsd.cafe

I'm reading about a Word "clone", apparently made by the same people who recreated "clones" of Adobe's software suite.

I don't know how legal any of this is, and I'm not going to get into that. But I can't help smiling at the reactions.

When they started pushing AI, they told us we would lose our jobs, whether we liked it or not. That AI would replace us, whether we liked it or not.

Now that someone has decided to apply the very same principle to their products, suddenly they don't like it anymore.

"You can create new games, but you can't recreate existing ones."

Hurts, doesn't it?

And that's the point. The problem isn't the technology itself, but the way certain sharks use it at other people's expense. When they're the ones on the receiving end, and only then, ethics suddenly becomes a concern again.

Refresh interactions
239 boosts
The origin reports boosts but does not publish who boosted this post.
Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Argo
@openfreenet @mastodon.bsd.cafe
Public en edited

@stefano, AI and robotics will not clone only Word but also the majority of workers. So we had to change our economic model, because there will be no many jobs left in the future. This will be mandatory.

From a technological point of view I'm very optimistic: automation, green energy, durable goods, etc...

From a social point of view, I have many more concerns because power corrupts, and as you noted, our ethic is far from optimal :-/

EDIT: and I am also frightened by the chaos of the intermediate period

Replying to @joel@tumfatig.net
Stefano Marinelli
@stefano @bsd.cafe

@joel s...sure πŸ˜†

Replying to @joel@tumfatig.net
Stefano Marinelli
@stefano @bsd.cafe

@joel to be fair, I haven't used a Microsoft Office product for...decades?

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Flous :dwm: :arch: :netbsd:
@lgeurts @fosstodon.org

@stefano Loudly agree.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Christoph Thiede :verified:
@LinqLover @norden.social

@stefano Well I'd still feel bad for all the LibreOffice and OnlyOffice and Collabora and Co. devs if people just started migrating to a soulless AI clone of Word whose generation was only possible because being trained on the public code of Libre & Co.

Stefano Marinelli
@stefano @bsd.cafe

@LinqLover I'm sure (wise) people will still prefer LibreOffice to those solutions. But maybe this could be the first step towards the Open Source world.

I'm sure there are tons of good use cases for those original Microsoft Office products. I just don't like the imposition of them.

Some Italian public offices still send "docx" documents that are full of things that aren't compatible with LibreOffice.

This makes me mad. You cannot force me to *buy* a closed, proprietary software solution to fill a public form.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe

@stefano@mastodon.bsd.cafe @LinqLover@norden.social Thankfully all the forms I need are provided as pdf. On the writing front I quite like LaTeX. πŸ˜‰

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
NeonkAaa
@nk @sns.neonka.info

@stefano
Not addressing Italian ones. But one time we applied for a gov tender, and it was required to upload some doc created only using a specific version of Word (before 2008). Because yes, the same doc saved in the modern Word (but the same format) did not pass the auto validation.
@LinqLover

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
MarjorieR
@marjolica @social.linux.pizza

@stefano @LinqLover well what market is there for a LibreOffice clone?
LibreOffice is free.
Their AI clone is inherently uncopyrigthable and probably wont work, so there's no money in it and in a non-monetary way bragging rights, up to the point it's reviewed and people try to use it.
The big threat to LibreOffice is from its own code getting enshittified. But I suppose we can always just use an old, pre-vibe-coded version.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Hyperlink Your Heart
@hyperlinkyourheart @mastodon.ie

@stefano I'm not inclined to use any of these "cloned" products, and I don't think they balance out the harms of the technology, but I do enjoy seeing generative AI used against its creators 😏

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
PypeBros
@PypeBros @mastodon.social

@stefano so we should actually ask AI to design GPUs for us ?

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Colin van den Akker
@colinvandenakker @mastodon.social

@stefano If large firms try to use Generative AI to hollow out worker's rights, then of course that needs to be opposed. But maybe we here have a case in which GenAI can be used to humble a rent-seeking monopoly (primarily Adobe); then I see no reason to object to it.

(Provided that the executables are not malicious. In the Snap repository, ArtCraft etc are offered as sandboxed programs, seem to work as intended, and require no AI for operation.)

(I'm sticking to Libre for everyday use.)

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Kentaur
@Kentaur @mastodon.social

@stefano This is the situation when the ice cream is licking back. πŸ˜†

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Maduraimari
@Maduraimari @mastodon.social

@stefano I am Muthumari from Tamil Nadu. After my small business revenue dropped, I fell into debt and made mistakes that I have now completely overcome. Today, I am in a severe financial crisis and urgently need support for my son's medical needs and basic family survival.
I fully understand online fraud makes it hard to trust strangers, but my situation is genuine. Any advice, guidance, or financial aid would mean the world to me.
#MutualAid #HelpNeeded #Crowdfunding #EmergencyHelp

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Drew Crecente (they)
@crecente @games.ngo

@stefano

Would love a non-AI "clone" of Adobe's suite from before they moved to a subscription model.

Our (small) non-profit has to maintain an air-gapped Win 8.1 box so we can still run the suite of #Adobe software we purchased in 2008 or so. (Installed with DVDs!)

It was only ~$120 to buy a generous Adobe suite as a registered #charity. We have tons of content we'd created and occasionally update images / video / audio -- but must keep the unsupported computer offline.

Adobe's "discount" program is considerably less charitable since they've moved to SAAS. (Not interested + not affordable.)

🀀 Satisfying to watch #bigTech eat itself.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Toni Aittoniemi
@gimulnautti @mastodon.green

@stefano This is the problem when engineers have been given the keys to the castle..

Engineers only think about what a technology DOES, not about to WHO does it do it for.

And these new engineer-kings have reduced any sense of morality to game-theoretic utilitarian equations, for which they hold a religious creed.

But being engineers, they never see their humanity, not one bit. And their models don’t count it in you or me either.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
mzni
@mzni @mastodon.social

@stefano
This is completely legal as long as you didn't literally steal their source code from their repositories. It's a beautiful thing because it breaks corporate monopolies, but it can also hurt independent developers and emerging startups.

#AI #OpenSource #TechPolicy #Copyright

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Old Fucking Punk
@lwriemen @librem.one

@stefano No the problem is the technology as well, when the technology is so poorly built that it requires massive data centers, causing social and ecological harms. These people using it to recreate imitations of bad products might be fighting the monopolies, but they are also contributing to the social and ecological problems by increasing the usage numbers. It's like an indiscriminate protest bombing that doesn't care about the collateral damage.
#DumbAllOver

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Hare-Brained Luddite
@wild_cube @mastodon.social
Public en edited

@stefano The funniest part is that ai clones of shit don't even have to be all that good. Execs don't even have to use their remaining brain cells to recall that open source alternatives have existed for ages.

All the ai clones have to do is just look the part and fool the idiots in charge like it did the first time they fell for it, and it's enough for those spinless worms to fill their trousers.

Such blissful, pathetic irony :)

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Wiz4rd_of_Aus
@Wiz4rd_of_Aus @mastodon.social

@stefano The AI bubble needs to burst already. I'm sick of it.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Kevin Ashworth
@kevinashworth @mastodon.social

@stefano
You cannot steal. They can.
Dystopian.

Replying to @stefano@bsd.cafe
Hdunagan
@hdunagan @mastodon.social

@stefano There just won't be any sympathy from folks who used to buy and own software but now have to pay yearly subscription fees. Tiny Violin for Adobe and Microsoft.